An diofar eadar na mùthaidhean a rinneadh air "Uicipeid:Doras na coimhearsnachd"
Content deleted Content added
Loidhne 1,094:
:::When I joined nl.wiki it had 400 pages. So, I have seen this discussion many times before. It is not unusual for wiki's at this stage to have many stubs. In fact they are often ''seeds'' more than ''stubs'': they are a way to grow and collect more info. But they also look messy. So, there is a trade-off. If you 'clean up' by setting high demands you kill off much that could have grown, but if you have too much of a mess you scare off people who don't like getting their hands dirty. As long as this wiki is as small as it is I would not make the requirements too stringent. Start with a few very basic demands. You can always make them stricter once gd.wiki has grown above, say, 100,000 pages. Also: improving seeds is better than putting them on a deletion list. And putting deletion/improvement tags on pages does ''not'' improve them for a reader. [[Cleachdaiche:Gunmhoine|Gunmhoine]] ([[Deasbaireachd a' chleachdaiche:Gunmhoine|an deasbaireachd]]) 20:29, 10 dhen Fhaoilleach 2015 (UTC)
::::We don't have articles on basic subjects... and the one on "nature" has just been deleted. (Couldn't a longer article be written?!). My problem is I would have trouble writing on some of these subjects ''in English'', but no one else seems to want to improve them. School children should be able to use this website for homework.
::::Our other problem is that there is very little Gaelic literature. Christian books and poetry, but that's it, and most of the rest dealing with Gaelic culture (but a lot of those books have English titles too). Most of the Gaelic language TV channel, BBC Alba seems to be in English too.
::::"you scare off people who don't like getting their hands dirty." - Many people have been scared off Gaidhlig wikipedia. Some people would like to see me scared off it too. -[[Cleachdaiche:MacRusgail|MacRusgail]] ([[Deasbaireachd a' chleachdaiche:MacRusgail|an deasbaireachd]]) 12:51, 11 dhen Fhaoilleach 2015 (UTC)
| |||